Available Soon: Request your printed copies of the Idaho Freedom Index mailed to you!
Request Your Copies
Note to Dustin: This is currently only visible to logged in users for testing.
Click Me!
video could not be found

Property: From Stars to Steads

Property: From Stars to Steads

by
Ronald M. Nate, Ph.D.
November 19, 2026
Author Image
November 19, 2026

You might be old enough to recall perennial holiday offers years ago to “Buy your loved one a star.” That’s right, for a price you could own a star and even name it after your sweetheart. But what did ownership really mean? What could you do with that star? And were you truly the sole owner, if an owner at all?  

Fortunately, property here on Earth is a lot easier to understand and appreciate. However, the concept of property isn’t always clear or absolute. And when government enters the mix, it can be both a help and a hindrance to what property owners regard as their rights. Let’s talk about houses and homesteads.

What is Property?

Political philosopher John Locke rightly identifies how social contracts are “...an intention in every one the better to preserve himself, his Liberty and Property.” 

Which leads to the question: Just what is property? Simply stated, property is a bundle of rights, and “[T]hese rights describe what people may and may not do with the resources they own: the extent to which they may possess, use, develop, improve, transform, consume, deplete, destroy, sell, donate, bequeath, transfer, mortgage, lease, loan, or exclude others from their property.” Cooter and Ulen, Law & Economics. 

In Idaho, homeowners have only limited authority to exercise their bundle of rights even when they are not imposing costs or harms to their neighbors or their neighbors’ property. Too often, our property rights are limited, not to protect neighbors, but seemingly just to control our behavior — it’s frustrating to have to beg the local government for “permission” to exercise a right.

On the other hand, sometimes a homeowner’s exercising of their rights can and do affect neighbors. Activities might be noisy, smelly, ugly, cause smoke, impede access, or otherwise annoy neighbors, and Idaho law has mostly reasonable limitations for those purposes. 

Recently, some areas of property rights law in Idaho have given rise to conflicts and may need law changes to address. Ideally, the law should ensure property rights are protected for homeowners while mitigating concerns for neighbors.

Property Rights Protections

Here are just a few of the areas of Idaho property law needing some attention:

ADUs. Just this past legislative session, Idaho lawmakers passed Senate Bill 1354, ensuring Idaho homeowners retain the right to build Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) — an additional living space in their home or a detached apartment on their property — without fear of local governments rejecting them. However, the law is still restrictive regarding the types and numbers of ADUs protected. There is more work to do here. 

Chickens. Given the current turmoil in the world (communications, flights, supply chain disruptions, etc.), some families see the need for maintaining their own minimal agricultural endeavors including keeping some small livestock — chickens, goats, etc. The problem is Idaho law is unclear on whether chicken ownership is a protected right, permissible entitlement, or an earned privilege. Further, some local governments, even down to homeowners associations (HOAs), show a desire to limit or ban chickens and farm animals from residential neighborhoods. Lawmakers still have work to do in defining a proper pecking order for small, urban and residential chicken operations — protected from HOA encroachments. 

Improvements. A friend in Lewiston related a story of how it took him 25 years (yes, a quarter century) to finally get permission to build a commercial building on a piece of zoning-ambiguous land he owned. The process should never happen this way in Idaho. 

Say you want to build a shed in your backyard. Do you know what must be done to do it without breaking the law? Are there permits, fees, inspections, limitations, or other details you must obey? From a pure liberty perspective, you should be able to do what you want with what you have, so long as it does not harm or affect others. But Idaho law doesn’t work that way. Many local laws require begging for permission, paying fees, and jumping through a number of hoops to finally be allowed to build on your land. 

Being left alone. When you own your home and land, you should be free from others — especially the government — doing things impacting you, your family, or your property. But that’s not what happens. Mosquito abatement, pesticides, and weather modification programs are just a few examples of how government imposes itself on property owners. The debate isn’t whether those programs are efficient and beneficial, but whether property owners are afforded the opportunity to be fully informed and to give consent before abatements and sprays are applied and wafted their way.

HOAs. Homeowners associations can be great ways for collective decisions to preserve and protect neighborhood communities and mini-cultures. However, Idaho Freedom Foundation has been alerted many times to how the authority of HOA boards is being abused. When HOAs impose binding rules affecting property owners, the “bundle of rights” are diminished and harmed. An HOA, for example, might try to impose rules about how many guests you may host in your home for parties or extended stays. Such restrictions are losses of property rights. Idaho law should be very clear on what HOAs may do and the process for doing it, with an eye to protecting property owners from tyrannical boards. 

Zoning changes. Similar to rules changes coming from HOAs, any time a local government changes its zones of use and/or the rules governing particular zone definitions, the bundle of rights of those property owners is affected. Local government must be constrained in its ability and desires to restrict property or change the rules, especially after owners are accustomed to current rules. 

Taxes. Already covered in other articles (just this week, for example), Idaho Freedom Foundation’s plan to eliminate property taxes is the ultimate policy in re-establishing a pure right to homeownership without the threat of seizure by government. Whenever a property tax exists, owners do not truly possess their property so much as rent it from government. Property taxes should be eliminated in Idaho.

Idaho Should Lead the Way on Property Rights

Idahoans must be fully secure in their constitutionally protected rights, among these are the rights to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness — and as Locke put it — property. When property is impacted, the Constitution must be followed.

Remember this nugget from The Communist Manifesto: “The theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property” (Marx and Engels). Idaho must never aid and abet the Marxists, and diminishment of property rights takes us in that direction. 

Heck, if you can own a star (to any extent), it shouldn’t be much to ask to fully own your homestead — and build a shed when you want to, not be charged tax-rents to keep it, and not worry about encroachments from government officials or nearby homeowners.

View Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Idaho Freedom Foundation
802 W. Bannock Street, Suite 405, Boise, Idaho 83702
p 208.258.2280 | e [email protected]
COPYRIGHT © 2026 Idaho freedom Foundation
magnifiercrossmenucross-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram