Bad Returns: How Idaho college degrees fare on debt-earnings tests

Bad Returns: How Idaho college degrees fare on debt-earnings tests

Anna Miller
December 7, 2021

Students and parents no longer need to ask, “Is college worth it?” The latest report by the Idaho Freedom Foundation’s Center for American Education explains the financial prospects of studying in a particular field at Idaho’s colleges. Stakeholders deserve to know which programs are serving students well and which should be held accountable by policymakers and college administrators or trustees by either being improved or canceled. 

Financial outcomes are not the only measures of program quality. Personal fulfillment can be a higher value for many students. Similarly, a program captured by Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) and no longer upholding the university’s core mission, to pursue truth, is another measure that should be considered. However, public universities are subsidized by the government and have a special burden to demonstrate whether taxpayers, parents and students' dollars are being spent wisely. 

New data on graduate earnings and debt in Idaho from the U.S. Department of Education helps students, parents, college administrators, and policymakers distinguish between programs where student loan debt can be worthwhile and programs that are financially risky. This report uses a robust assessment measure by combining the Gainful Employment Equivalent (GEE), measuring annual earnings and discretionary income rates, and a Debt as a Percent of Earnings, median student loan debt as a percent of earnings two years after graduation, to evaluate college programs. The report assesses 163 of Idaho’s programs, which account for 80% of all bachelor’s degree holders and 53% of all associate degree holders.

As should be expected, this combined assessment measure reveals that performance varies greatly among academic fields. Among bachelor’s programs across the state's higher education system, several were assessed as “excellent,” including engineering disciplines, business-related disciplines, and health-related disciplines. The worst performing disciplines, two years after graduation are law, English literature, design and applied arts, history, anthropology, and sociology. 

Several of these worst-performing fields tend to be disproportionately populated by left-wing faculty and captured by DEI, which does not contribute to student well-being on campus and may mean that graduates are perceived as out of step with Idaho’s prevailing cultural values. Additionally, data for some degrees from departments dominated by DEI is unavailable. This could be due to a small number of graduates in such programs or another data reporting issue. These degrees include English and gender studies at Boise State University and education, anthropology and English at University of Idaho. 

Every associate degree program was scored as “excellent” with only two exceptions, both at Idaho State University (general liberal arts, scoring “Terrible”, and medical assisting services, scoring “Good”). Associate degree programs are so successful in providing a positive return on investment that there is no good reason to further subsidize community college tuition to make it cheaper or “free.” 

Parents and students should beware of programs of highest concern at Idaho’s universities. 

Additionally, policymakers should focus their accountability efforts on these worst-performing programs assessed as “poor” or “terrible.” Our report identified 19 programs which graduate approximately 675 students per year, many with high-risk or excessive debt. Six of these programs are at University of Idaho and include Intercultural/Multicultural and Diversity Studies, political science, international relations, parks and recreation, fine arts and law. However, as noted in the report, the nature of a discipline such as law may not be suited to assessment just two years after students graduate. Another eight of these programs are at Idaho State University and include English, social work, sociology, anthropology, liberal arts, history and geological sciences. The worst performing program in the state is the masters degree in student counseling and personnel services at Boise State University, where graduates have more than $57,000 in debt but are earning less than $35,000 annually two years after graduation. 

Programs rated as mediocre that should be monitored and are increasingly pursuing DEI include sociology, anthropology, history and special education and teaching at Boise State University and sociology and history at the University of Idaho. 

Overall, degree programs at Idaho’s public institutions aggregately rank 37th out of the 50 states in debt-earnings assessments among graduates, far below neighboring Utah, which ranked 1st, and far above neighbor Montana, which ranked 46th. 

College administrators and trustees can use this report to better serve their students. Wise colleges will seek to expand successful programs and phase out or reform those that are financially dangerous for students or prioritize DEI rather than the cause of knowledge. 

Similarly, policymakers can hold institutions of higher education accountable with this fine-grained tool. The report recommends exercising program-level accountability, which means that particular programs can be funded or defunded, deregulated, or monitored more closely on the basis of an objective, numerical standard. 

The president of the State Board of Education has previously stated the need for “hard data” to objectively measure concerns around higher education. Student loan debt and post-graduation earnings are vital data needed to hold colleges accountable to taxpayers. The data presented in this report can be used to supplement other important measures considered by the legislature to assess programs including graduation rates, life satisfaction, and promotion of DEI. Idaho’s public officials have an excellent opportunity to expand programs that are succeeding and serving students well, especially in the health professions, while holding the worst performers accountable. 

Download the report here: Bad Returns: How Idaho College Degrees Fare on Debt-Earnings Tests

View Comments
  • KJ says:

    The trade schools are a better choice for a productive society. We don't need people with a degree in gender studies.

    The cost of a trade school is a whole lot cheaper than a college degree that is becoming more worthless by the day.

    A college degree won't get you the job you want because University degrees don't guarantee stable careers anymore.

    According to the WSJ, “At more than half of schools, at least a third of seniors were unable to make a cohesive argument, assess the quality of evidence in a document or interpret data in a table”. The outcomes were the worst in large, flagship schools: “At some of the most prestigious flagship universities, test results indicate the average graduate shows little or no improvement in critical thinking over four years.”

    The Boise campus would actually serve a useful purpose as a training facility for carpenters, auto mechanics, plumbers, etc. Instead the kid get a huge bill for a worthless degree.

  • Cara ivens says:

    What about religious studies ?

  • john livingston says:

    During my 44 years as a physician and surgeon I spent well over half of that time instructing medical students and surgical and medical residents. The diligent students who became great doctors taught themselves. They were self-motivated and curious and relentless in their desire to learn. Attributes taught to them by their parents, not their professors. The smartest and most educated man I have ever known was an Alaskan crab fisherman who did not graduate from high school. He could quote Socrates and Plato and The Bible and Shakespeare. He taught himself calculous and physics. Abraham Lincoln spent less than two years in school. Thomas Jefferson was educated by a home tutor Our colleges and universities that used to provide opportunities for learning have become citadels of indoctrination. Wokeness and CRT have little relevance on a job site, on a crab boat or in the operating room. There is more value in learning how to work and think than there is in learning how to be politically correct. STEM studies are a means to an end. Most other studies are an end unto themselves---a dead end. Thanks Anna for pointing that out.

    • Bobby W says:

      So...Anna Miller didnt submit her resume, including her academic studies, when applying to IFF? She mustof been a helluva crab fisherman to get this gig.

      • john livingston says:

        Bobby W
        Hiring a person---man or woman, who had worked in the Alaskan King Crab Fleet for several seasons to manage any of my businesses, would be less risky than employing a gender studies major or graduate student in CRT. Same thing with hiring a tradesman. I always prefer people raised on a ranch or people with rural values. I also prefer to hire people who competed at something----not just participated at something----business and sports. Anna was a college athlete, economics major, and master's graduate. Work and compete. Anna would make a "helluva" crab fisherman, no question about it. Don't ya think?

        • Bobby W says:

          I guess so. She's acceptable at IFF because she didnt study STEM classes, right? Isnt that the IFF viewpont, Mr Livingstone?
          And, you know, doncha, that her alum school has CRT as a class but you attack BSU, which doesnt?

        • Bobby W says:

          Was Anna Miller on scholarship on a non-revenue team? If so, how is that not socialist while she accuses idaho teachers of being socialist? She's a product of a woke system!

    • KJ says:

      Good comment. I might add that a critical thinking course must be added to the curriculum early on. One would have to think that this is a no brainier....

  • Idaho Freedom Foundation
    802 W. Bannock Street, Suite 405, Boise, Idaho 83702
    p 208.258.2280 | e [email protected]
    COPYRIGHT © 2021 Idaho freedom Foundation
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram