Available Soon: Request your printed copies of the Idaho Freedom Index mailed to you!
Request Your Copies

House Bill 499 – Granting police officer membership to emergency communications officers for retirement purposes

House Bill 499 – Granting police officer membership to emergency communications officers for retirement purposes

by
Niklas Kleinworth
February 2, 2022
Niklas Kleinworth
Author Image
February 2, 2022

Bill Description: House Bill 499 recognizes emergency communications officers as police officers for the purpose of granting them more favorable retirement benefits.

Rating: -1

Analysis:

Does it increase government spending (for objectionable purposes) or debt? Conversely, does it decrease government spending or debt?

Generally, Idaho state employees wait until they turn 65 years old before they can collect the benefits they earn from the Public Employment Retirement System of Idaho (PERSI). However, employees may collect their benefits earlier if the sum of their age and years of service equals 90. This provision is known as the Rule of 90.

Due to the physical and mental strain public safety workers go through on the job, they are allowed to collect retirement benefits sooner than other PERSI beneficiaries. Rather than retire under the Rule of 90, they can take advantage of something called the Rule of 80. Under this rule, employees may collect their benefits once the sum of their age and years of service equals 80. Under Title 59, Idaho Code, this option is open only to police officers and firefighters.

HB 499 defines approximately 580 Idaho emergency communications officers (dispatchers) as police officers for the purpose of retirement, qualifying them for the Rule of 80.  This would increase government spending on PERSI contributions by 0.34%.  This translates to $69,000 to $132,000 in additional annual expenditures statewide.

(-1)

Analyst’s note:

Although this appears to be a small benefit increase for a narrow group of employees, it could have significant consequences for the structure of the PERSI benefit system.  Many justifications can be made for why many state employees should qualify for the Rule of 80.  In this case, the Statement of Purpose for HB 499 highlights the marketability of retiring sooner when recruiting dispatchers.  Other state agencies can and do make similar arguments for their employees.  Opening this aspect of the program beyond firefighters and police officers could make state retirement plans a larger expense down the road.

Despite the fact that PERSI is well funded now, it is important to remember that we are in an extremely long bull market by historical standards. Once an employee retires, they are no longer contributing to PERSI and their pension must be covered by other active members and taxpayers. Given the current trajectory of the United States economy, it is irresponsible to expand the state’s obligations to PERSI retirement plans.

View Comments
  • jre says:

    Is it known who the sponsor of this bill is?

  • Erin Hidalgo says:

    The critical position of an Emergency Communications Officer requires a specific set of cognitive skills, many of which diminish with age. While aging in general is a factor for everyone, people’s lives are not dependent upon the decision making skills and mental acuity of everyone. The longer someone is an Emergency Communications Officer, the poorer their skills are, not only due to the natural aging process but due to the nature of the job itself.

    In 2017 legislation was enacted requiring ECO’s to have mandatory training and certification by the Peace Officers Standards and Training Council. In 2019 legislation was passed to include Post Traumatic Stress Injuries in Workman’s Comp for First Responders. First Responders are those persons who qualify for the Rule of 80. Emergency Communications Officers are First Responders as defined by Idaho Code.

    I would happy to answer any questions you might have.

    Erin. A Hidalgo
    9-1-1 Supervisor
    208.785.1234

  • Idaho Freedom Foundation
    802 W. Bannock Street, Suite 405, Boise, Idaho 83702
    p 208.258.2280 | e [email protected]
    COPYRIGHT © 2022 Idaho freedom Foundation
    magnifiercrossmenucross-circle
    >
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram